By Fester:
Watching the John McCain strategy briefing for victory is painful. It sounds like a senior class project where the student has a predetermined result in mind and is trying to be agile enough to get the right arguments into place even if they don't make sense. The one thing that lept out at me was the following map from Ohio and Pennsylvania ( about 8:13 in). I have modified the map a little bit by adding a couple of geographic pointers:
In 2000, Allegheny County was about 6% more Democratic than the nation as a whole, and in 2004, Allegheny County was about 9% more Democratic than the nation as a whole. And yet this map is projecting that it will flip to McCain, or at least it is implicitly arguing that due to the color schema. This is not the only type of flip that the McCain camp is projecting. Erie County is about 4% more Democratic than the nation as a whole, and it is projected to flip. Beaver and Washington counties were even splits. The only SW Pa county that went overwhelmingly for Bush and has a significant population was Westmoreland. Allegheny County floods out the region due to its population and mobilization rates. A lot of trees and coal mines are in the probable McCain counties, but not a lot of voters.
Ouch, this is just a painful distortion of reality that the McCain campaign wants to persuade its supporters that they can see an effective ten point swing in their favor compared to Bush in Allegheny County. Their best hope is keeping the margin close but that is an unlikely hope. Sad....

Because you probably don't listen to Rush Limbaugh, you won't have heard of Operation Chaos in which tens of thousands of Republicans and Independents switched party affiliation for a day to vote for Hillary but intend to vote GOP in November.
ReplyDeletePlus, given the legendary "open-minded, non-judgmentalism" of liberals, many folk keep "Democrat" on their county voting rolls to just avoid hassels. "Reagan Democrats" are real.
John --- I live in Pittsburgh so I know the region fairly well. I agree that Reagan Dems are real but I also know that the counties with significant populations tend to vote for Democrats at the state (gov) and federal levels (Pres & Senate) with the exception of Westmoreland County. The population anchor of the region; Allegheny County is about 9 points more Democratic as expressed by the vote share of Gore and Kerry --- that includes defections of Reagan Democrats who voted for Bush in large numbers in Pa-4 and Pa-18. So even accounting for Reagan Democrat defections, McCain would need to run about 10 points ahead of Bush in SW Pa to win the swath he is targetting. I find that unlikely.
ReplyDelete