Commentary By Ron Beasley
I grew up on anti war songs in the 60s and we've had dammed few of them when we've needed them recently. They don't get the play they got in the 60s and early 70's but they are out there and here is a good one.
Of course the anti war songs of the 60's may have been a bit more subtle;
Great finds, Ron. I have a hard time listening to the old music of the Sixties without getting emotional. Only lately did I learn that Sag Mir Wo Die Blumen Sind has been around longer than the Sixties, having been first popularized by Marlene Dietrich.
ReplyDelete(You Tube is an intoxicating place. I tripped over a version by Maryla Radowicz, a popular contemporary Polish singer about our age.)
The biggest difference between the Vietnam Era and now was the draft. Like all my peers I was opposed to the draft when I was drafted in 1965, but since then I have changed my mind. The celebrated "all volunteer" military has resulted in the kind of cowboy attitude described in the Rolling Stone article and "civilian oversight" has become a hollow platitude. Difficult subordinates made me a better manager, not those who faithfully followed instructions. Likewise, military commanders would behave differently and be more effective if some of their subordinates were not as enthusiastic as they about waging war. McChrystal and his inner circle illustrate the point vividly.
No one was ever conscripted to any branch of service but the Army. The other branches have always been "all volunteer" even with the draft in place because more young men wanted to avoid (they thought) becoming cannon fodder. If the draft were now in place the body bags and flag-draped coffins would carry a very different message. Even those who "volunteered" would be remembered differently and the war in Asia would be a lot less popular.